Ready to Help You Fight for a Fair Result CONTACT US TODAY
Wooden gavel and books on wooden table

Sixth Circuit: Sex Offender Check-Ins Aren't a Seizure

November 16, 2026 Nov. 16, 2026

On November 13, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, the federal appeals court that covers Kentucky, Ohio, Michigan, and Tennessee, ruled that requiring people on a sex offender registry to report to police in person does not, by itself, amount to a "seizure" under the Fourth Amendment. The case is Does v. Michigan State Police, No. 25-1415 (read the opinion). It is recommended for publication, which means it is binding precedent in federal courts throughout the circuit, including the Eastern and Western Districts of Kentucky.

What happened

A group of registrants challenged three in-person reporting requirements under Michigan's Sex Offender Registration Act (SORA): registering in person after release, periodic check-ins (one to four times a year, depending on the person's tier), and reporting within three business days after life changes such as a new address, job, school, or name. They argued that being ordered to show up at a police agency is a seizure of the person.

A three-judge panel (Judges Moore, Nalbandian, and Mathis, with Judge Moore writing) affirmed the dismissal of that claim. The court relied on its earlier decision in Willman (2020) and compared registry reporting to a grand jury subpoena or a court summons, which are legal obligations to appear that courts have not treated as seizures. The court noted that registrants generally choose the day within their reporting window, so a reasonable person would feel free to end the encounter. The court decided only whether there was a seizure; it did not decide whether the requirements are reasonable.

The court did leave a door open. It said additional restrictions, such as barring a person from leaving the state, could change the analysis. On the same day, in a related case, Doe v. Whitmer, No. 25-1413, the Sixth Circuit addressed other challenges to Michigan's law, finding a procedural due process problem with how people with out-of-state convictions are registered and sending certain ex post facto claims back to the district court (summary on Justia). For a short write-up of the Fourth Amendment ruling, see FourthAmendment.com.

Why it matters

Kentucky has its own sex offender registration law with its own reporting duties, and federal courts here follow Sixth Circuit precedent. This decision makes it harder to challenge routine in-person reporting as a Fourth Amendment seizure. Registration is a long-term obligation, and failing to meet a reporting requirement can itself lead to a new criminal charge.

For anyone facing a charge that could carry a registration requirement, in state or federal court, the practical lesson is that the consequences of a case can last long after the sentence ends. Understanding those consequences before making decisions about a plea or trial is critical.

Talk to a defense attorney

If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in Owensboro, Western Kentucky, or federal court, the Law Office of B.J. Early, PLLC can help you understand your rights and options. Call (270) 447-5540 today for a free consultation.

This post is for general information only and is not legal advice. Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future matter.